The Seat Pleasant 59: Part Two

After reading the first article by Paul Schwartzman about the 59 fifth graders from Seat Pleasant Elementary, I couldn't resist. I had to keep reading. Schwartzman has me hooked on this story of a philanthropic movement to help kids from a community achieve the unexpected. This part two of the story's trilogy focuses on the fifth graders as they moved through middle school, who made it through high school, and those who achieved the original goal of graduating college. I enjoyed reading about Darone Robinson, who was definitely Schwartzman's main focus of this article and how he had to move on from the death of his cousin, struggle to overcome problems in high school, fights, make it to college, and then walk across the stage with a diploma. After reading through a couple of the student's stories, I see how college is not always the dream for every kid in America, whether there is too much violence or not enough money. I can definitely say I have taken my plans to go to college for granted because I am very lucky that I will have the opportunity to attend a university and further my education. Not going to college was something I couldn't really understand, but Schwartzman helped me see the other side.

Once again Schwartzman's main appeal is pathos with his audience. The audience can't resist reading about this opportunity these kids were given and want to know the outcome. We root for them, and want them to overcome all odds. The emotional tone keeps the audience intrigued, however once again, Schwartzman throws around a couple of the kids names without giving a description that can help the audience remember which student is which and what Schwartzman has previously wrote about them. I guess this calls for efferent reading and multiple read throughs. The author's honesty is another technique that appeals to the audience. For example, Schwartzman writes, "it was clear that not everyone was going to make it to college" (Schwartzman 2). Some authors could've tried to butter up the situation and make it seem like all of the students' success came from this investment in their college education. But, not Schwartzman. He makes it clear to the audience the truth of what happened to the 59 fifth graders, even if they did not make it to college.

Source: Schwartzman, Paul . "The Reality: Daunting difficulties for the children promised college scholarships." The New York Times 17 Dec. 2011, sec. Local: n. pag. The New York Times. Web. 21 Dec. 2011.